MAGNETIC NORTHS
Copyright: International Boundary Research Group, Durham University, United Kingdom.
Open

CHARLES STANKIEVECH’S COMMENTARY

From afar, the shifting phenomenon of magnetic north provides guidance not unlike Polaris, but as one draws close to the shadowy realm of the Arctic, navigation and communication begin to go awry, forcing the nomad to experiment within a no-man’s land. Military and religious colonization, hazardous testing, and a disregard for a fragile ecosystem mark the past of the Arctic, but so do inventive and sensitive histories. Within the White Cube of the gallery — here posited as a substitute for the minimalist landscape of the Arctic Sublime — the exhibition takes as its starting point Mercator’s imaginative speculation of dual magnetic north poles from 1595, and ends with recent geomatic renderings by an indigenous government. Between these visual landmarks, a constellation of documents, photographs, sculptures, radio broadcasts, film screenings and installations weave together the overlapping territories of utilitarian artifacts and conceptual artwork. The survey of work starts with techno/military enterprises such as those of Thomas Edison, R. Buckminster Fuller, Canada’s NFB, and the US Air Force; revisits conceptual art from the 1960s and ’70s by Glenn Gould, N.E. Thing Co., Lawrence Weiner, Michael Snow, Joyce Wieland and others; and includes a selection of contemporary artists whose work combines both axes. Far from being an empty terra incognita, the Arctic, and like it, Magnetic Norths, functions both as a historical repository and as a fantasy projection space that generates electro-magnetic distortions, pay dirt, pissing contests, sci-fi warfare, psychedelic skies, conspiracy theories, critical confections, shamanistic loss and shattered cartographies.

A constellation of concepts to navigate the exhibition:

AURORA BOREALIS: Whether believed to be spirits travelling across the sky or solar radiation colliding with the magnetosphere, the northern lights have captured the imagination of elders, explorers, scientists, tourists and artists alike. Before this past century, we did not understand solar radiation interacting with the magnetosphere created such luminescent skies, and with this epistemological gap folkloric explanations flourished, ranging from ghost stories to people claiming they can hear them. Nowadays, we can create the outer space light show artificially, with high-powered ionospheric radio experiments like the High Frequency Active Auroral Research Project (HAARP) or High Altitude Nuclear Explosions (HANE).

BOUNDARIES: “A border is not a connection but an interval of resonance” said Marshall McLuhan, discussing the Arctic region of Canada between Russia and the United States. Like the drifting snowbanks of the tundra, the northern landscape is constantly in flux, both geologically and politically. Here boundaries are not only fluid and constantly under negotiation, they overlap and bleed into each other. The Arctic Circle, commonly thought of as a line existing at 66ºN, is in actuality a shifting zone based on celestial movement, while the debate over what should be considered “North” has been a long-standing issue, not limited to the political demarcation known as “North of 60.” After decades of negotiations, Land Claims in the North have finally been agreed to between the Crown and First Nations (as recently as the last ten years). Now they are being further negotiated between sovereign First Nations, who must adapt to a type of mapping incongruent with the nomadic hunting patterns exercised on their Traditional Territory. At the same time, Canada has been known to justify sovereignty within the Arctic archipelago using the argument aboriginals migrate across the ice: fancy footwork in the effort to exercise jurisdiction over the melting Northwest Passage, which countries around the world desire to exploit for faster shipping routes. Furthermore, in hoping to gain more real estate from which to extract natural resources, polar countries around the northern hemisphere are attempting to expand their jurisdiction northward, beyond the traditional 200-nautical-mile coastal buffer zone, using scientific claims that a nation’s continental shelf extends under the Arctic Ocean. There are few places on earth with so many internationally disputed boundaries, continually shifting due to celestial, cultural, economic, political and scientific pressure.

CBC: The Canadian Broadcasting Corporation is a Crown corporation created in 1936 and utilised as a nationalist propaganda media network via radio and TV, and now, additionally, via the Internet and satellite radio. The CBC has a special division for the North that includes custom programming for the region with attention to local community events and languages. Over the years, the CBC has also commissioned a host of new compositions, such as R. Murray Schafer’s North/White for orchestra and snow machine, and produced a variety of ethnomusic recordings, as well as a number of radio and TV documentaries, including Glenn Gould’s seminal “Idea of North” radio documentary of 1967.

CONCEPTUAL ART: During the 1960s and ’70s a style of conceptual art emerged in Canada that constructed the triad: landscape – performance – document. In some scenarios, the performance was paired with the artist and the document with a theorist or critic. The paragon example of this type of production was in a Northwest Territories expedition involving N.E. Thing Co., Lawrence Weiner and Harry Savage along with Lucy Lippard. The creation of these ephemeral works—urinating in the snow or walking around the city for NETCO, shooting a rifle and diverting water for Weiner, and freezing ice into chains by Savage—would have largely gone unnoticed in the remote location if not for the documentation of the projects by Lippard, who photographed the production of the work and then later wrote about it. NETCO formalised this symbiotic relationship in their piece “Lucy Lippard Walking Toward True North,” drawing attention to art’s normally invisible partner and placing her into the frame of the aesthetic landscape she created in tandem through her written contextualisation.

DOCUMENT: In a landscape subject to extreme change from season to season, a “land” that is sometimes composed of frozen water, and a region remote from the majority of a nation’s population, the document is necessary to communicate ephemeral events that transpire in a remote environment. Whether it takes the form of a sound recording by Glenn Gould or Jean-Jacques Nattiez, a poster from an N.E. Thing Co. performance, an NFB documentary, or a photographic essay on the Alaskan Pipeline by the Center for Land Use Interpretation, the document is necessary to present an idea, event or place that few people are able to witness in person. Not possessing such documents creates the same problematic situation faced by the explorers Cook and Peary when trying to prove that they had in fact reached the North Pole. Inversely, because of the planning necessary to conduct projects in the North, sketches, blueprints, maps and other utilitarian documents are needed to ensure the successful implementation of such ventures. Both types of documents thus become artifacts and residues of endangered cultures or executed expeditions.

FIELDWORK: A fieldwork engages with the geographic site but then warps one’s perception of the space comparable to a mathematical “strange attractor.” Sharing, on the one hand, the history of art installation (which can modulate the encompassing architecture and the viewer’s phenomenological perception) and on the other hand, the history of “site-specific” or earthwork art (which amplifies the place’s story or materiality), a fieldwork creates its own temporary architecture within a space or in a landscape. However, such a landscape need not be natural and the architecture may not always be a traditional shelter or sculpture, but can be composed of sonic material, electromagnetic fields, light fluctuations, or relationships. At its core, a fieldwork is dynamic and geospatial.

GEODESIC RADOME: First built in Germany prior to the Second World War to house the Zeiss planetarium in Berlin, the geodesic dome was popularised by its American patent-holder, R. Buckminster Fuller. During the early 1950s, Fuller collaborated with the MIT’s Lincoln Laboratory and the US Department of Defense to create the first ridged radar domes, or radomes, to house Arctic radar antennas capable of functioning in severe wind, temperature and ice conditions, while being efficient to transport and assemble. The distributed engineering design of the geodesic was a precursor to the ARPANET program and can be a seen as a symbol of modern warfare’s shift from direct conflict on a shared front to contemporary electromagnetic combat via distributed networks. By the end of the 1960s, the geodesic dome’s iconic status as DEW (Distant Early Warning) architecture had been subverted by alternative cultures like Drop City as a means of expressing Fuller’s concept of “Spaceship Earth” and ecological concerns. Today, geodesic domes represent the ambiguity of invisible military operations in the electromagnetic realm, as well as counter-culture utopias—all while referencing another type of polar dome: the igloo.

HOTHIAN WARFARE: Few regions are as visibly marked by the presence of military experimentation and infrastructure as the Arctic, even though, ironically, there is little if no history of active combat in the Arctic Theatre. Because of its involvement in telecommunications, the establishment of settlement outposts, scientific support, mapping, training and exploration, the military has a long history in the Arctic—perhaps because few other organisations can afford the investment needed to work in the environment or feel the extreme need to be present in the harsh climate (petroleum corporations being the major exception). Spawned by the film Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back, the term “Hothian Warfare” refers to strategies in polar regions that use advanced technology verging on the fantastical. These include, but are not limited to, ALERT and DEW radar outposts, High Altitude Nuclear Explosions (HANE) and missile testing, the stratospheric Strategic Defense Initiative (STAR WARS), the High Frequency Active Auroral Research Project (HAARP), patrolling nuclear submarines surfacing through pack ice, remote drones exploring the seabed and floating nuclear oil exploration stations off the coast of Russia.

LANDSCAPE: Whether one looks at the Group of Seven, Emily Carr, Glenn Gould, Margaret Atwood, R. Murray Schafer, or other iconic Canadian artists across all genres, it is clear that the landscape plays a defining role in the ideology of “Canadian Art.” Even artists from abroad come to Canada to situate their work specifically within the Canadian landscape; for instance, such works as Robert Smithson’s first planned earthwork (the unrealized Island of Broken Glass), Lucy Lippard and Lawrence Weiner’s expedition to Inuvik, N.W.T. with N.E. Thing Co., or Andy Goldsworthy’s natural sculptures in Nova Scotia. The Landscape is not only place, it is also material and a force to be reckoned with. In the case of the Arctic—the most iconic of Canada’s ecosystems—the minimalist landscape retains a particular aura of fantasy, as a place where both nothing and anything can transpire much like Andrei Tarkovsky’s “Zone.”

MAPPING: The Arctic is difficult to represent in any form—best exemplified in its status as one of the last places on earth to be mapped. With the standard Mercator projection (the one we are familiar with from scholastic walls and Google Maps), the territory is increasingly distorted as one moves north, to the extent that the North Pole is infinitely expanded into a line across the top of the map. But without maps, nationhood cannot be defined, resources cannot be claimed, and transportation routes cannot be set. As a result, the map —whether carved into Inuit tactile coastal maps or created with the latest in geomatic technology—becomes a condensed site of ideological projection. This is as true for the fantastical Mercator map of 1595, which depicts a magnetic mountain and four continents at the North Pole, as it is for the reclamation of Traditional Territory from industrial and political forces by the Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in First Nation’s government.

NATIONAL FILM BOARD (NFB): Although perhaps best known worldwide for its auteur animation films, the NFB is also synonymous with the invention of the “documentary” genre under the theoretical guidance of John Grierson, the first to use the term and the founding NFB commissioner. As an arm of government interested in developing audio-visual media for social change, the NFB’s work has gone through several phases, ranging from war propaganda at its birth in the 1940s and ’50s, to more culturally focused productions that serve as the billboard for an ethnically diverse nation with a continuing focus on Northern Identity.

NO-MAN’S / NOMAD’S LAND: Throughout history, the Arctic has been seen as a “no-man’s land,” the last frontier, or just an empty space to conquer and extract resources from. Thankfully, however, because of the increasing acknowledgement of the indigenous population that traditionally migrated across the tundra and ice, following herds of caribou and other animal life, the region is now seen more as a nomad’s land full of history. This point is especially notable when the Arctic is contrasted with Antarctica, where there is no indigenous human population and only the recently arrived scientists and tourists who are nomadic in a different sense.

OUTER SPACE: Our aesthetic of Outer Space shares a similar aesthetic with the Arctic: utilitarian outpost architecture, a barren landscape and the harshest of weather replicate “off-world” existence. Tethered to the more populated world by a network of trade and supply while remaining shrouded in mystery, it is no wonder, then, that science fiction and fantasy films often place secret bases at the Poles or use a frozen stage set, where a psychological and geographical “aesthetic of distance” is inherent. Continuing a well trodden stage of Arctic spectacle, a quick sampling of blockbuster films demonstrates our fascination with the Polar world as “other world”: Superman’s crystal Fortress of Solitude, Ozymandias’ Antarctic base in Watchmen, Blade Runner‘s off-world replicants’ residence in the Yukon Hotel, the Predator vs. Alien hunting gauntlet buried deep under the ice, the Golden Compass‘s evil research facility Bolvangar, Frankenstein’s final demise as witnessed by a North Pole expedition, and so on. Inversely, in the conceptual art world, Michael Snow’s film La Région Centrale used his imagined version of moon footage to frame his vision of the North: “The film will become a kind of absolute record of a piece of wilderness. Eventually the effect of the mechanized movement will be what I imagine the first rigorous filming of the moon surface.”

RADIO: Precipitated by the Klondike Gold Rush, the US Army started experimenting with wireless technology in Alaska (and possibly the Yukon, as precise maps were just then being drafted of the disputed region). Appropriating the derelict Overland Telegraph Line from the mid 19th century, by 1902 the Army worked with Marconi’s company to complete the system with wireless telegraph connections between remote bases, creating one of the earliest wireless communications networks and connecting the Arctic to the rest of the continent. Eventually this system would evolve into the ionospheric troposcatter networks of White ALICE and the DEW Line before rising upwards into satellites. Today HAARP is the next-generation experimental radio research station, buried away in the interior of Alaska a few hours from the Canadian border and shrouded in a veil of mystery. On the civilian front, CBC links the northern landscape together with its nationalistic broadcasts, connecting isolated communities across the vast landscape.

SHAMANISM: Part of the Inuit cosmology, shamanism represents an interesting precursor to Canadian performance art in the Arctic, where landscape, ritual and myth are interwoven. With the advent of colonialism and evangelicalism, shamanism declined as a binding cultural force. It is possible that modern practices such as filmmaking and the other arts will rejuvenate this lost role in a contemporary world where old and new cultures collide.

SOVEREIGNTY: From the initial migration of Arctic aboriginals (First Nations, Inuvialuit and Inuit) to the twenty-first-century carving up of the Arctic Ocean seabed like a cake to be devoured, the issue of sovereignty is continually evolving in the North—partly because of its nomadic population (indigenous people, civilian contractors and military personnel), partly because it borders on so many different nation states, and partly because of the developing body of knowledge about the region. Exacerbating this situation are the vast untapped natural resources counterpointed by the significant cost in fiscal resources to patrol, defend and occupy the area. In the past, Canada has used various tactics to enforce sovereignty, such as forcing the relocation of Inuit to maintain occupation, and intends, in the future, to increase its military presence and upgrade satellite surveillance.

WARM WAR: The Warm War is the new conflict arising around the issues of sovereignty and ownership of natural resources in the polar regions as a result of global warming.

Charles Stankievech
Tuktoyaktuk, Beaufort Sea, Arctic Ocean
New Year’s Eve 2010

Produced with the support of the Frederick and Mary Kay Lowy Art Education Fund.

A project by Charles Stankievech

Exhibition produced by the Leonard & Bina Ellen Art Gallery with the support of the Canada Council for the Arts.

THE WORKS

List of Works

AKUFEN
My Way: “Deck the House”, 2001
Sound recording with LP cover

BLACK CAT SYSTEMS
Russian Number Station, 1993
Sound recording

LANCE BLOMGREN
Operation Northern Shield, 2008
Poster and fictional essay
Courtesy of the artist

CENTER FOR LAND USE INTERPRETATION
Trans-Alaskan pipeline, 2008
Colour photograph
Courtesy of CLUI Archive

Thule warming hut, interior, 2006
Colour photograph
Courtesy of CLUI Archive

THOMAS EDISON
Klondike Films, 1867-1901
Silent b/w films transferred to DVD

R. BUCKMINSTER FULLER / MIT Lincoln Laboratory
Prototype of First Rigid Radome, 1952
Photograph
With the permission of the MIT Lincoln Laboratory, Lexington, Massachusetts

GLENN GOULD
The Idea of North, 1967
Recording of CBC Radio broadcast

Sketch for the Prologue from “The Idea of North”, 1967
Reproduced with the permission of Library and Archives Canada, CBC, Lorne Tulk, and the Glenn Gould Foundation

Poster of CBC Broadcast of “The Idea of North”, 1967
Reproduced with the permission of Library and Archives Canada, CBC, and Glenn Gould Foundation

LAURENT GRASSO
HAARP, 2007
HD video projection, colour, sound, 3 min. 20 sec.
Courtesy of the artist

TIM HECKER
Sonic Palimpsests: “Dawson”, 2008
Sound recording

Haunt Me, Haunt Me, Do it Again: “Boreal Kiss Pt. 1, 2, 3” +
“Night Flight to You Heart Pt. 1, 2”
, 2001
Sound recording with CD cover

ZACHARIAS KUNUK and NORMAN COHN
The Journals of Knud Rasmussen, 2006
Digital video, colour, sound, 112 min.
Distributed by VTape, Toronto

ALVIN LUCIER
Sferics, 1980
Sound recording with LP cover

GERARDUS MERCATOR
Septentrionalium terrarum descriptio / Per Gerardium Mercatorem cum privilegio, 1595 – 1602
Map of the Arctic with dual magnetic North Poles
Collection of Library and Archives Canada, Ottawa

PETER METTLER
Picture of Light, 1994
35 mm film, colour, sound, 83 min.
Distributed by Grimthorpe Film Inc., Toronto

EMILY MIRANDA
Arctic Passion Cake (after Joyce Wieland), 2010
Styrofoam and icing
Courtesy of the artist

N. E. THING CO.
Territorial Claim – Urination, 1969
C-prints, type-written text, labels, offset lithography, paper and foil seal on paper
Collection of the Morris & Helen Belkin Art Gallery, University of British Columbia, Vancouver

Lucy Lippard Walking Toward True North, 1969
Silver gelatin print, felt pen, paper and metal foil seal, b/w offset lithograph, black printing ink, black paint on board
Collection of the Morris & Helen Belkin Art Gallery, University of British Columbia, Vancouver

DAVID NEUFELD
BAR 1- DEW line Archive, 2009 (online version)
CD-Rom, 1996
Courtesy the artist

R. MURRAY SCHAFER
North /White, 1973
Score
Courtesy the artist

North/White, 1973
35 mm slide projection of performance with R. Murray Schafer
Slide courtesy of Simon Fraser University Library, Burnaby

KEVIN SCHMIDT
Wild Signals, 2007
HD video projection, colour, sound 9 min. 43 sec.
Courtesy of the Catriona Jeffries Gallery, Vancouver

MICHAEL SNOW
Drawing for camera activating machine, “La Région Centrale”, 1970
Black porous pointed pen on paper
Collection of the Art Gallery of Ontario, Toronto

La Région Centrale, 1971
16 mm film, 180 min.
Distributed by CFMDC, Toronto

2 Radio Solos: “Short Wavelength”, 1980
Sound recording with cassette cover

The Last LP: “Speech in Klogen performed by Okash, Northern Finland”, 1987
Sound recording with LP cover
(LP Cover) Private collection, Montreal

CHARLES STANKIEVECH
DEW Project, 2009
Installation with radio broadcast and video
Courtesy of the artist

TR’ONDËK HWËCH’IN FIRST NATION, LANDS & RESOUCES BRANCH
Traditional Territory Land Claims with Placer Mining Claims (Yukon), 2009
Map

UNITED STATES AIR FORCE / GENERAL ELECTRIC
Project 572: DEW Line Radar Unit #6 BD 6-3 A
Blueprint 1956, reprinted 2009

UNITED STATES AIR FORCE / NAVY / DARPA
High Frequency Active Auroral Research Project (HAARP) Pulse Signal, 2000
Sound recording

LAWRENCE WEINER
The Arctic Circle Shattered, 1969
Vinyl on wall
Courtesy of the artist

LAWRENCE WEINER and WILLIAM FURLONG
Concerning 20 Works, 1980
Sound recording

JOYCE WIELAND
Arctic Passion Cake (sketch), 1971
Pen and black ink on wove paper
Collection of the National Gallery of Canada, Ottawa

True Patriot Love / Véritable amour patriotique, 1971
Catalogue for the solo exhibition held at the National Gallery of Canada in 1971
Private collection, Montreal

The Arctic Belongs to Itself, 1972
Lithograph on paper
Private Collection, Montreal

OSWALD WIENER and HELMUT SCHOENER
Animal Music: Team of Jeremy Roht, West Dawson, 2001
Sound recording with CD cover

DOUGLAS WILKINSON
How to Build an Igloo, 1949
16 mm film transferred to video, 10 min. 27 s
Distributed by The National Film Board of Canada

Explore

By experiencing these works you can explore:

  • notions of scale and infinity;
  • physical and sensorial experiences that are either referred to or produced in this exhibition and how they relate directly to landscape;
  • sovereignty and ownership. How are these addressed here?
  • mapping and boundaries and how these are addressed by works in this exhibition. What is their significance in terms of current political concerns in the Arctic?
  • nomadism and the ways in which this notion is an important consideration in Magnetic Norths.

A FEW QUESTIONS

  • How do the various artists represented in Magnetic Norths address space and time? Do you notice similarities and differences in the ways they do this and, if so, what are they?
  • Consider the ways in which notions of broadcasting and communications function in this exhibition. How are they significant and do they tell us anything about the Arctic and their importance there?
  • What relationships are drawn here between landscape and material?
  • How are the ephemeral, the impermanent, and the dematerialized represented in these works?
  • What role does the document play in this exhibition and what is its importance?